Home Appraisal Impacts on Your Mortgage: Tips for Budgeting

Buying a home is thrilling. It’s also a financial puzzle. One key piece? The home appraisal. It might not get as much attention as your credit score or interest rate. However, there are home appraisal impacts nevertheless, as they can make or break your mortgage approval – and your budget.

With that in mind, let’s dig into what appraisals really mean for your mortgage, how they’re calculated, and how to prepare for the unexpected.

What Is a Home Appraisal and Why Does It Matter?

A home appraisal is an independent assessment of a property’s value. It’s used by lenders to make sure the amount you’re borrowing reflects the actual market value of the home.

Why? Because lenders want to protect their investment. If you default on your loan, they need to know they can recoup their money by selling the property.

According to the FDIC, an accurate appraisal safeguards both the lender and the buyer by preventing overpayment and keeping the loan-to-value (LTV) ratio in check. This ratio affects how much you need for a down payment. It also affects your interest rate.

What Influences Appraisal Values?

No two appraisals are the same, but here’s what usually goes into one:

• Comparable sales: The recent sale prices of similar homes in the area.
• Property condition: Age, renovations, layout, and general upkeep.
• Market trends: Is it a buyer’s or seller’s market?
• Location: Proximity to schools, amenities, crime rates, and more.

Federal guidelines from HUD also require appraisers to meet standardized reporting and data delivery formats, especially for FHA-backed loans. These systems aim to promote fair, unbiased property valuations. However, bias still happens.

A Philadelphia Fed study found that about 30% of appraisals matched the sale price exactly, suggesting there might be pressure to hit the agreed-upon number. That means you, the buyer, might not be getting the most accurate picture.

How Do Appraisals Affect Mortgage Approval?

Appraisals are critical in the loan approval process. If the appraised value comes in below the purchase price, it can derail your mortgage approval. Or force you to renegotiate the terms.

A low appraisal increases the LTV ratio, which in turn may require a larger down payment. In some cases, lenders might reduce the loan amount or deny the loan altogether. In fact, low appraisals have been shown to raise mortgage denial rates by 1.8 percentage points.

And the 2009 Home Valuation Code of Conduct (HVCC) didn’t help much. After it was introduced, low appraisals surged by 2.1 percentage points overall. And by 4.7 points in states hardest hit by the financial crisis.

Budgeting for Appraisal Surprises

So, what can you do if the appraisal throws a wrench in your plans?

Start by building a buffer into your budget. Don’t count on every dollar of your pre-approval letter.

Here are a few tips:

• Understand appraisal costs early on so you’re not caught off guard. They typically range from $300 to $600. Learn more about potential appraisal costs.
• Save for a higher down payment. This gives you room to maneuver if the appraisal is low.
• Keep cash reserves. Some lenders want to see that you have enough to cover two to three months of mortgage payments.
• Negotiate with the seller. You may be able to meet in the middle if the appraisal comes in low.
• Challenge the appraisal. If you believe it was done incorrectly, you can request a review or submit additional comparables.

How Sellers Can Prepare for the Appraisal

Sellers, this part’s for you.

A poor appraisal can tank your deal, even if the buyer is ready and willing. So make sure your home is appraisal-ready.

Here’s how:

• Clean and declutter. First impressions count. Even in valuations.
• Highlight upgrades. Provide documentation for recent renovations or upgrades.
• Fix obvious issues. Cracked windows, leaky faucets, or worn-out flooring can all drag the value down.
• Know your market. Research local property pricing trends to ensure your listing aligns with current values.

What Happens If the Appraisal Comes in Low?

It’s not the end of the road. But it is a fork in it.

Here are your options:

1. Renegotiate the price. If the seller agrees, everyone wins.
2. Increase your down payment. Make up the difference to keep the mortgage terms.
3. Walk away. If your contract has an appraisal contingency, you may be able to exit the deal.
4. Order a second appraisal. Especially if you suspect the first one was off-base.

Still, lenders lean on appraisals to keep the market stable. According to the GAO, consistent, accurate appraisals are key to consumer protection and financial system integrity.

Conclusion: Be Prepared, Not Surprised

Home appraisals can feel like a black box. But they don’t have to derail your plans. By understanding how they affect your mortgage, preparing for the costs and potential pitfalls, and knowing how to respond when things don’t go as expected, you’re putting yourself in a position of power.

Plan. Build a budget buffer. And remember: Your home is more than a number, but that number still matters.

Photo Credit: stock photo