Is a college degree necessary? Well … possession of a university degree is still an important factor for many employers. So the question that we should really consider is whether having a degree is the only door to a successful future.
Forty-one percent of university students drop out before the completion of their degree, according to a recent report released by the United States Department of Education. While the attainment of a degree is the objective of going to university, it’s inaccurate to say that drop outs do not gain any benefit from the time they have spent at the university.
The distinction we need to make is between those who never attended a university, those who attended but dropped out, and those who were awarded a university degree. By making this comparison, we might be able to answer the main question as to whether or not a university degree is necessary today.
Career Choice
The career choice young people make when they complete their schooling is the very first factor that we need to take into account. Those who choose to enter one of the trades by becoming an artisan or tradesman, obviously do not have to attend university to qualify in their chosen field. They would, however, have to attend a trade school or other vocational education institute to become properly qualified.
For those choosing to enter fields of activity where membership of a professional society, such as the American Medical Association or the National Society of Professional Engineers, is obligatory in order to practice in your chosen field as a professional, a graduate degree is an essential. Individuals choosing a military career as an officer have to attend university or a military academy in order to progress through the ranks of commissioned officers and achieve leadership roles in their particular field.
The next group we look at are those that attended university but dropped out before completion of a degree. The major reasons for dropping out, according to a Harvard University study, is the inability to cope with the academic demands of the selected course, shortage of funds to continue and a desire to enter the workplace for various reasons such as money, good job offers and the realization that a college degree is not essential. The other group are those that drop out in order to go into business.
The Professional Path
Those who have chosen professional career paths where the individual would be in private practice such as physicians, dentists, attorneys, or accountants, while the others, more in the science and engineering fields, would typically be employed in the private sector. The attainment of a university degree would, in the vast majority of cases, ensure a secure and moderately wealthy lifestyle with the same degree of security following through into retirement.
While it is impossible to examine all the various professions and degree courses, the importance of acquiring a university degree remains. There are naturally many spheres of employment where a degree provides an advantage, but is not an essential, with workplace experience often compensating for a lack of educational qualifications. Employers very often tend, however, to give preference to educational qualifications and youth ahead of experience which generally goes with age.
The Drop Outs
Invariably, whenever this subject comes up for discussion, somebody is sure to come up with a list of names of those who succeeded, despite having dropped out of university. They will reel off names such as Bill Gates, Mark Zuckerberg, Larry Ellison and the late Steve Jobs among others who not only succeeded, but became world renowned and enormously wealthy. Two of them are among the ten wealthiest men in the world, and while several others are the beneficiaries of inherited wealth, Bill Gates and Larry Ellison are self-made successes.
It’s important to note however, that although some of these individuals dropped out of university, they started out in activities mostly related to the world of computers with business partners who they had met while at university. While they might not have a degree, being at the university means that they meet like-minded people who play a role in their future successes.
Bill Gates started out playing around with computers and doing programming while still at school and even wrote an algorithmic program at a very early stage. This type of algorithmic program became an essential part of the development of the online trading platform similar to that which millions of online investors engaged in binary options trading use. While not for one moment discounting the success of Microsoft and what it has meant, the algorithmic program has earned billions for online traders globally.
Where Are They Now?
The latest data available indicates that there were more than 21 million students at universities and colleges in the US last year. With a dropout rate of 41%, this means that around 8 million students drop out in every five or six year cycle. Although we hear about the few drop out success stories we discussed earlier, we rarely hear about the millions of other students who also drop out.
Those who achieve university degrees and then go on to succeed in the professions as well as in business, remain anonymous in most cases, but far outnumber the small minority of dropouts who succeed beyond expectations.
Is a College Degree Necessary?
The ability to succeed in life seems to be enhanced by attending university, while the completion of the full curriculum and being awarded a degree must certainly be considered worthwhile. The degree of specialization we find in some fields of endeavor have made specialist education an essential need. This need can only be filled in an academic environment, such as a university, for the betterment of society and the world at large.
Having said all that, while a university degree is necessary in many activities, artisans, craftsmen, and many others without degrees fill a vital and important function in our day-to-day lives. So … is a college degree necessary, or not? The answer to the original question must then lie in the choice of career, with some requiring a university degree as an essential, while others do not need to have the same amount of academic input to be useful and active members of society.
Photo Credits: stock photos
Ramona says
Hmmm.. pretty tough.
I’d say it’s worthless, based on my experience. My degree has absolutely nothing with working for 10 years as a radio DJ or working as a web designer since 2002 (and running a pretty lucrative online business).
But I do want my daughter to go to college though, since I do find it’s important to have a degree. Maybe she’ll continue in her specialty, maybe she’ll just reinvent herself as I did before, but she should go to college.
While my degree per se wasn’t useful, I did learn some pretty important stuff and it’s been useful to me.
Len Penzo says
My take is that it depends. Science, technology, engineering and math degrees … usually (see my next comment below).
Other than that, I think the answer is “buyer beware.”
Adam Harlow says
It really comes down to work experience or degree and before you make the decision to go to college you should look at what you want to do with your future. That can help determine if the degree is a good idea or not. As you have mentioned, there are a lot of big shots that did not need college to make lots of money. They just seem to have the mind for it. Other like myself need to learn from others to be successful. I am just finishing my MBA and it has been truly valuable to myself personally and my career.
Lauren P. says
I’m glad folks like Mike Rowe are promoting trade schools in lieu of a 4 yr. degree. Like many others, my oldest had no idea what he wanted to do upon high school graduation. He took the “trades” route and has a well-paying job that can’t be outsourced. He also owns his home and makes more than I ever did (w/a 5 figure Christmas bonus, to boot!)
That said, I’m happy for folks who do the college thing if it’s for a worthwhile profession like teaching, law, medical, etc.
Len Penzo says
Fantastic, Lauren!
My son is working for a very large (Fortune 50) company in IT making a six-figure salary (he started there last year at the age of 26). He is completely self-taught; never spent a day in college – and is a high school drop-out (his dyslexia and ADD were not conducive to book learning). He boldly applied for the job even though it required a college degree in software engineering. The company interviewed him anyway – and then gave him a technical test to make sure he could really do the work. Well … he aced it!
Bottom line: Don’t let anyone tell you that you need a college degree to get a good-paying job. All you need is experience (even if self-taught), a little moxie, and the ability to prove you can do the job.
Lauren P. says
Kudos to your son, Len. It seems he’s learned MUCH that college might not have taught him, like self-esteem, confidence and to TAKE THAT CHANCE! You must be so proud of him. He should consider mentoring others w/learning issues; what a great example he could be for them. 🙂