How Fees Quickly Erode Your Savings Account Returns

Remember when this was considered a paltry return?

Your savings are a long-term investment, and whether you have accounts for short term purchases to furnish your home or fill your wardrobe, or whether you have your emergency fund and bill payment funds saved in the same place, you have worked hard to earn your money.

You have also worked hard to be disciplined enough to save it in the first place — so why would you allow your savings to be eroded by fees?

The easiest mistake to make when it comes to choosing a savings account is thinking that account fees won’t make much difference to your overall savings.

Examples of Fee Effects on Your Return on Investment

Consider a $10,000 investment in a higher-interest savings account, over 12 months. This investment amount and term will give you a very good illustration of how seemingly insignificant fees can adversely affect the return you get on your savings investment.

Here is a breakdown of the assumptions:

  • An interest rate of 4.11%. Don’t laugh. Yes, the rate is higher than what is currently offered on the market today, but it represents an approximate average over the years. This rate does not include a bonus or promotional rate, as a 12 month investment is a long term savings plan, and a bonus rate would not apply for the entire time.
  • Transaction fees. A higher-interest savings account is just like any other bank account in that it allows you to make deposits and withdrawals at any time. Online higher-interest savings accounts and linked transaction accounts have a certain number of free transactions included. However, if you use more than your designated number of transactions, you’re charged a small transaction fee which can range from 25 cents to $1 depending on your financial institution. In the second scenario we have assumed two additional transactions per month, at 25 cents each.
  • Monthly fees. If an account charges a monthly fee you generally have all of your access and transactions included for this amount. For the third scenario we’ve assumed a reasonable average monthly fee on savings accounts of $5.
  • Transaction fees and monthly fees. To show the culmination of fees on your savings account, our fourth scenario combines the monthly savings account fee charges and transaction fees described above.

Here is an example of how the various fee scenarios can effect your savings account return on investment (ROI):

No Fees 2 x $0.25 per month $5 Monthly Fee Monthly Fee + Trans- action Fee
Original Investment $10,000 $10,000 $10,000 $10,000
Total of Fees Over 12 Months $0 $6 $60 $66
Return on Investment (ROI) $419.54 $407.27 $358.21 $345.94
ROI Losses Due to Fees n/a $12.27 $61.33 $73.60

How to Maximize Your Return on Investment in a Savings Account

Even a seemingly small monthly fee or insignificant transaction fee can significantly affect the ROI you can get from your savings account. It is also important to note that the difference in ROI when savings were invested in an account with monthly or transaction fees was more than the amount of the fees. This is because in a higher-interest savings account, interest is calculated daily and so while a monthly fee of $5 and transaction fees totaling 50 cents per month add up to only $66 in fees over 12 months, the difference in your ROI is more than $73 because you are missing out on that compounding interest.

To get the best return on your investment:

  • Take the time to find a fee-free online savings account. Choosing a dedicated higher-interest savings account allows you to avoid all fees which will affect your ROI. An online savings account will have no monthly service fees and will not charge you transaction fees for making deposits or withdrawals, no matter what the amount.
  • Link to a fee-free transaction account. Making sure your higher-interest savings account is fee-free is only the first step as fees can eat away at your savings from the outside too. The account you use to make deposits to your savings fund may attract monthly or transaction fees and these eat into your overall funds, and can affect the amount you are able to contribute to your savings each week.
  • Make regular deposits to your savings. As mentioned earlier, compounding interest means that every day your balance grows so too do your interest earnings, increasing your return on investment. Therefore, each day or week that you can make a deposit to your savings gets you closer to a higher ROI, rather than you making one larger deposit at the end of each month or quarter.
  • Choose a savings account which rewards you with a higher ROI. If you know you can make regular deposits to your savings fund, choose an account which offers you bonus interest when you fulfill a minimum deposit requirement. Or, if you know you won’t be making withdrawals, choose a higher-interest savings account which offers you bonus interest to boost your ROI in the months you don’t make withdrawals.

About the Author

Fred Williams writes for Credit Card Finder, where he helps people to compare credit cards and savings accounts online.

Photo Credit: ursonate

(This is an updated version of an article originally posted on March 2, 2010.)



Comments

  1. 1

    says

    I find it amazing that so many banks get away with charging all these fees. Isn’t it puzzling that their customers accept these fees? I suppose these fees are usually so small that you don’t notice them but they do add up. A while ago a colleague of mine told me that he switched from Chase after he tallied up the fees they charged him in a year. He came close to $500.

  2. 3

    Richard says

    It’s amazing how quickly fees can erode away the benefits of savings. There are plenty of online saving accounts charging no fees it seems crazy to pay fees.

    • 4

      says

      It does seem crazy, Richard, but many people are just too preoccupied (to put it nicely) to spend a little time to do the research necessary to avoid paying those fees.

  3. 5

    Money-AU says

    The best way to clear hurdles and build your savings is to stop making excuses and get started.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>